I'm replacing a few well-worn, well-loved items. Or trying to.
They're just purses, but this experience is an example of principles covered in the book, "The Design of Everyday Things," written by Donald Norman a few years ago.
The purses I'm trying to replace had a clean, classic design.
Just the right size and shape, nice leather, they didn't have a lot of flourishes, logos and doo-dads.
More than that, though, they WORKED. Perfectly.
Just enough pockets, in all the right places, and all the right sizes for a phone, pens, and a few other oft-needed retrieved and stored items.
Finding a replacement for a few simple purses should be easy, right?
Not so, I discovered.
And, it turns out, this is a more common problem than I suspected. A client has a similar problem, unfortunately. It's just a hassle neither of us needs or wants (I liked shopping at one point. Not anymore).
And because of that, I bought one recently that seemed "perfect enough."
I should have taken it for a test drive.
It was beautiful, elegant, and vaguely intriguing, with a slightly unusual shape. And it was on sale.
The problem with that beautiful purse? For all its surface elegance, it does not WORK. It's a junker, a clunker, in use.
It's too deep, too subterranean in design and yet, too compact to find things easily without unpacking and then repacking it, multiple times a day. (It's a bit like having a tightly-packed grocery bag that has to be completely unloaded just to retrieve one simple thing).
This beautiful-but-it-doesn't-work bag reminds me of something my mother used to say about beautiful buildings.
"This probably won the architects an award, but they clearly didn't have to LIVE in the building they designed!" she would say in exasperation when something created more hassles than it should have, in use.
Do you know the feeling, too?
Think back to the last product or service you bought that fit solidly in the category of, "It's beautiful, but it doesn't WORK."
- Was there a simple design change that might have made all the difference in usability of the product or service?
- Did your experience change your likelihood of recommending that brand to other buyers in the future?


